Skip to main content

Swat strategy of ‘winning hearts’ hard for US to emulate

LAHORE: Teenagers in the former Taliban stronghold of Swat are smiling in relief, after the successful army operation against the Taliban in the valley has ended their days of forcibly working as boy soldiers.

A report in the Washington Post said the Pakistan Army had found hundreds of traumatised teenagers when its troops regained control of Swat in a violent campaign this summer.

About a month ago, the army opened a rehabilitation clinic for the war-torn teenagers.

It has been named “Sabaoon”, which is means “the first ray of light of the morning” in Pushto.

The report’s author said the military’s commander in Swat, Major Gen Ishfaq Nadeem Ahmad had warned him before he visited the facility that many of the boys were still shaken by their experiences.

But one of the youths had merrily stepped forward and shook hands with him.

The commander said the boy had been trained as a suicide bomber when he was rescued.

The report said it was the perfect way to defeat an insurgency. It said the teenagers would return home as living witnesses that the Taliban’s hold on Swat had been broken and that the army was serious about protecting the people.

“We told our majors and captains that people should fall in love with you,” Gen Nadeem said.

The author wrote that the commander’s claims became clear when they travelled through the valley without protective armour or other precautions, reflective of the fact that the army had considerable public support.

The commander said the roads were a no-go-zone six months ago, but they were now teeming with merchants and shoppers.

Some women were out in public even without burqas that the Taliban had enforced. The only Kalashnikovs to be seen were on billboards advertising a laundry soap that took after its name.

What the Pakistani army did differently was that it stopped trying to buy peace with the Taliban through deals that inevitably collapsed. In May, as the insurgency was spreading out of Swat towards Islamabad, the army finally decided to crack down, for real.

Pak plans: Gen Nadeem cited three factors in the campaign’s success.

First, the army sent enough troops to do the job – two divisions, totalling about 25,000 men, rather than the 3,000-man brigade that had failed to contain the insurgency before.

Second, to allow the use of heavy firepower, soldiers moved civilians out, creating more than 2 million internally displaced persons, who have now mostly returned, and third, the army had popular support from Pakistanis fed up with the Taliban.

The report said the execution had some lessons for US troops across the border in Afghanistan, but said a fact remained clear that the US, being an outside force, simply could not do some of the things that worked for Pakistani commanders.

“No matter how fervently Gen Stanley McChrystal speaks of a population-centric strategy, it is hard to implement if it is not your country,” the report said.

McChrystal’s strategy echoes some of the Pakistani precepts — more troops, more foccus on the population, more security.

“But even with an additional 40,000 troops, the United States won’t have the same popular support the Pakistanis enjoyed in Swat. America is fighting what many Afghans will always regard as a war of occupation. People aren’t going to fall in love with US troops,” the report added.

“The right Afghanistan policy begins with a frank admission that this isn’t America’s problem, it’s Afghanistan’s. The US needs to patiently support the emerging Afghan government, keeping our troop levels firm and reliable, until the Afghans acquire the tools and political consensus to secure their country,” it said.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

India's swine flu death rate is increasing

Friday, August 14, 2009 MUMBAI: A 26-year-old woman died Thursday of H1N1 swine flu in the southern city of Bangalore, raising India's death toll from the virus to 20, authorities said.The death was the first reported in India's information technology capital, the Press Trust of India reported.Meanwhile in Pune, the worst-affected in India, two more victims of the virus died Thursday, raising the death toll in that western city near Mumbai to 12, the report said. The victims were an 11-month-old boy and a 75-year-old old woman.US media reported movie halls, schools and colleges were ordered closed Thursday for three days to a week in Mumbai, the commercial and financial capital of the country, as fear of the pandemic spread.Prajakata Lavangare, a spokeswoman for the government of Maharashtra state of which Mumbai is the capital, said similar orders were issued in Pune, which is also located in the state.The woman who died in Bangalore was identified only as Roopa, a teacher in...

Suicide bombings kill 18 in Iraq

Thursday, August 13, 2009 MOSUL: At least 18 people, most of them members of the ancient Yazidi religious sect, were killed when two suicide bombers blew themselves up on Thursday in a packed cafe in northern Iraq, a local government official said.At least 31 people were also wounded after the bombers detonated suicide belts packed with explosives in the cafe in Kalaa town, in the district of Sanjar, local district chief Dakheel Qassem Hasoon, told a foreign news agency."Two suicide bombers entered the Cafe Barbaroz at 4:30 pm (1330 GMT) and blew themselves up, killing 18 civilians and wounding 31. Most of the victims were Yazidis," Hasoon said.Kalaa, northwest of the insurgent stronghold of Mosul in northern Nineveh province is predominantly populated by the minority Yazidi religious sect, as well as Arabs and Kurds.The attack is the deadliest since Monday, when 51 people were killed across Iraq, including 28 members of the tiny Shabak sect cut down when two truck bombs det...

US drones to target Taliban in Afghan war

Friday, July 31, 2009 WASHINGTON: The US military plans to use more drone aircraft to target Taliban militants in Afghanistan while focusing less on hunting down Al-Qaeda figures, report said on Thursday.Although defeating the Al-Qaeda terror network remains an overriding goal for Washington, officials now believe the best way to pursue that objective is to ensure stability in Afghanistan and neighboring Pakistan instead of Al-Qaeda manhunts, the paper said, citing US government and Defense Department officials.It was more important to prevent a slide towards violence and anarchy that could be exploited by Al-Qaeda, which used Afghanistan to stage its attacks on the United States on September 11, 2001, the officials said."We might still be too focused on Bin Laden," an official said. "We should probably reassess our priorities."The shift in priorities for the drone fleet comes despite President Barack Obama's declaration that defeating and dismantling Al-Qaeda ...