Skip to main content

Jinnah’s ancestral village seeks apology from Jaswant

Friday, August 21, 2009 GUJARAT: Residents of Moti Paneli, an obscure village in Gujarat’s Rajkot district, which is the ancestral place of Pakistan founder Muhammad Ali Jinnah have sought apology from Jaswant Singh, the author of “Jinnah-India, Partition, Independence” for denigrating Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel. Though these villagers take pride in the fact that M.A. Jinnah belonged to their village and also married here, they find it intolerable to see Sardar Patel, who was also a Gujarati and remembered for his role in the unification of India, be denigrated by anyone. These people have demanded an apology from BJP’s ousted leader Jaswant Singh. “Whatever Jaswant Singh has written is false. The allegations made by him against Sardar Patel are untrue. Sardar Patel was a great man and did some great things for India. Though Jinnah was from our village Paneli and we are proud of it… He grew up here and went to school…but Jaswant should apologise for whatever he has written,” said Manubhai Bhalodiya, Sarpanch (head of town council) of Moti Paneli.Villagers are agitated over BJP’s ousted leader Jaswant Singh’s reported remarks in his controversial book that put blame on Sardar Patel along with Pt. Jawaharlal Nehru for the partition of India. “I have read all the books on independence, Mahatma Gandhi, etc and I found out that whatever Jaswant Singh has said about Nehru and Sardar Patel that they were the villains during the Partition, is not correct. My analysis says that Muhammad Jinnah was responsible for the Partition from the very start,” said B. T. Bhalodiya, a local historian in Moti Paneli.Some elderly residents in Moti Paneli feel the Jaswant’s expulsion from the BJP was a right step and blamed the ousted leader for creating a controversy for publicity.“I think this is a publicity stunt to increase the sale of his (Jaswant Singh) book and the decision made by Bharatiya Janata Party to expel him is right. The party has taught him a right lesson,” said Bharat Bhai Hirani, a schoolteacher.Though Moti Paneli village also has other communities other than the Patels but when it comes to Sardar the village, they are united for his respect. As for Jinnah’s ancestral abode in Moti Paneli, it was sold over five decades ago and today one Vaishnav family resides here.Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) expelled its senior leader Jaswant Singh from the party on Wednesday (August 19) since he praised Muhammad Ali Jinnah and denigrated Sardar Vallabh Bhai Patel, which it found was against the party line. Sardar Patel played a major role in the country’s struggle for independence and guided its integration into a united, independent nationAs the first Home Minister and Deputy Prime Minister of India, Patel organised relief for refugees in Punjab and Delhi, and led efforts to restore peace across the nation during and after partition of the country.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

India's swine flu death rate is increasing

Friday, August 14, 2009 MUMBAI: A 26-year-old woman died Thursday of H1N1 swine flu in the southern city of Bangalore, raising India's death toll from the virus to 20, authorities said.The death was the first reported in India's information technology capital, the Press Trust of India reported.Meanwhile in Pune, the worst-affected in India, two more victims of the virus died Thursday, raising the death toll in that western city near Mumbai to 12, the report said. The victims were an 11-month-old boy and a 75-year-old old woman.US media reported movie halls, schools and colleges were ordered closed Thursday for three days to a week in Mumbai, the commercial and financial capital of the country, as fear of the pandemic spread.Prajakata Lavangare, a spokeswoman for the government of Maharashtra state of which Mumbai is the capital, said similar orders were issued in Pune, which is also located in the state.The woman who died in Bangalore was identified only as Roopa, a teacher in...

Tennis: Clijsters wins US Open, second time

NEW YORK: Kim Clijsters of Belgium won the US Open on Sunday by defeating Caroline Wozniacki of Denmark 7-5, 6-3 in the final.She is the first mother to win a Grand Slam title since Evonne Goolagong in 1980, the victory coming just five weeks after she returned to the sport following a 27-month retirement. She was the first wildcard, man or woman, to win a US Open title in the history of the tournament.

42 killed in wave of Iraq bombings

BAGHDAD: At least 42 people were killed and nearly 100 wounded in a spate of bomb attacks near the restive northern Iraqi city of Mosul and in the capital Baghdad on Monday, police said. In the deadliest single attack, two booby-trapped lorries exploded before dawn in the village of Khaznah, east of Mosul, leaving 25 people dead and 70 others wounded. Thirty-five houses were destroyed in the village, which is home to members of the tiny Shabak community, a sect of Kurdish origin. In Baghdad, two car bombs went off as day labourers were gathering in the early morning hours looking for jobs.The first bomb exploded at Hay al-Amel, in the west of the capital, killing nine people and injuring 46. The second bomb attack in Shurta Arbaa in the north of the city killed seven people and wounded 35 others.